Most Underrated Carry Pistols You Shouldn’t Overlook

When shopping for a concealed carry pistol, names like Glock, SIG Sauer, and Smith & Wesson dominate the conversation. While these are excellent firearms, they can often overshadow other quality models that deliver just as much reliability and performance. Many lesser-known or underappreciated handguns offer superb features, accuracy, and concealability that make them just as good if not better for everyday carry. In this guide, we highlight the most underrated carry pistols that deserve a closer look. Whether you're a seasoned carrier or a first-time buyer, these overlooked gems could be the perfect fit for your needs.

Walther PPS M2

Why It’s Underrated:
Walther is often underrepresented in discussions about carry pistols, but the PPS M2 breaks that mold. It's a single-stack 9mm designed specifically for concealed carry, boasting an ergonomic grip that feels molded to your hand. The slim, snag-free profile makes it easy to conceal under almost any clothing, and the trigger is among the best in its class.

Performance:
The PPS M2's accuracy is superb for its size, aided by its low bore axis and smooth trigger. It has a refined build with quality internals that hold up well to long-term use. Despite its compact size, it feels substantial in hand without being bulky. It also features front and rear slide serrations, making manipulation easy under stress.

Quick Specs:

• Caliber: 9mm

• Capacity: 6, 7, or 8 rounds

• Weight: 21.1 oz

• Notable: Superb trigger, slim profile

Best For: Everyday carry, shooters who prioritize comfort, and anyone looking for a slim and responsive sidearm for close-quarters defense.

Beretta PX4 Storm Subcompact

Why It’s Underrated:
The PX4 Storm Subcompact is part of Beretta's trusted PX4 lineup, but this smaller variant doesn’t get nearly the attention it deserves. It features a rotating barrel system, which significantly reduces felt recoil a feature rarely found in subcompact pistols. Its DA/SA configuration offers both safety and versatility, appealing to traditionalists and tactical shooters alike.

Performance:
The recoil control is what truly sets this pistol apart. Shooters will appreciate faster follow-up shots and reduced muzzle rise, even in a compact frame. Its built-in rail, interchangeable backstraps, and ambidextrous controls also offer customization and flexibility not commonly found in subcompact models.

Quick Specs:

• Caliber: 9mm / .40 S&W

• Capacity: 13+1 (9mm)

• Weight: 26.1 oz

• Notable: Decocker, rotating barrel, reliable operation

Best For: DA/SA fans, soft recoil lovers, and shooters who want tactical-level control in a compact carry gun.

Ruger LC9s

Why It’s Underrated:
The Ruger LC9s is a budget-friendly, striker-fired pistol that delivers consistent reliability. What sets it apart is its surprisingly clean and light trigger pull, which greatly improves accuracy in a compact platform. Its ultra-slim design makes it ideal for concealed carry, and it’s an excellent option for those just getting into EDC handguns.

Performance:
This pistol excels in concealability and simplicity. The textured grip helps control recoil, while its intuitive operation makes it beginner-friendly. It's perfect for appendix carry, ankle carry, or even purse carry. Although light, it's built with ruggedness in mind.

Quick Specs:

• Caliber: 9mm

• Capacity: 7+1

• Weight: 17.2 oz

• Notable: Manual safety, compact profile

Best For: Budget-friendly deep concealment, first-time buyers, and anyone who wants a no-fuss, lightweight handgun.

Kahr CM9

Why It’s Underrated:
Kahr's CM9 is designed for maximum concealability and minimalist carry. While it features a double-action-only trigger, it's incredibly smooth and consistent. The compact dimensions and lightweight construction make it ideal for pocket carry or deep concealment setups.

Performance:
Kahr’s engineering ensures minimal snag points and a clean profile for easy draw and reholstering. The DAO trigger has a long but deliberate pull, which many concealed carriers prefer for added safety in high-stress situations. The CM9 also features polygonal rifling for improved accuracy.

Quick Specs:

• Caliber: 9mm

• Capacity: 6+1

• Weight: 14 oz

• Notable: Long trigger pull, snag-free design

Best For: Advanced users who value a clean, snag-free design and appreciate the reliability of a simple, DAO mechanism in a super compact frame.

CZ P-01

Why It’s Underrated:
The CZ P-01 is NATO-certified and has passed some of the most rigorous testing procedures, yet it doesn’t get the mainstream attention it deserves in the U.S. market. Featuring an aluminum alloy frame, DA/SA trigger, and decocker, this pistol combines old-school ruggedness with modern ergonomics. It’s built like a tank but carries like a compact.

Performance:
Accuracy and control are where the P-01 shines. The full-size grip and ergonomically curved trigger allow for precise shooting and enhanced recoil control. Its reliability is unmatched, even in adverse conditions, making it a favorite among military and law enforcement abroad.

Quick Specs:

• Caliber: 9mm

• Capacity: 14+1

• Weight: 28.1 oz

• Notable: Alloy frame, DA/SA trigger, decocker

Best For: Shooters who want hammer-fired durability, military-grade reliability, and proven performance in the field or on the range.

Stoeger STR-9C

Why It’s Underrated:
The Stoeger STR-9C is a feature-rich, striker-fired pistol that offers incredible value for the price. With interchangeable backstraps, solid capacity, and Glock-style functionality, it’s an excellent option for those who want performance without spending a fortune. Despite being budget-friendly, the build quality and shooting experience are comparable to more expensive models.

Performance:
The STR-9C delivers a balanced grip, excellent sight radius, and intuitive control layout. Its trigger has a tactile reset, making rapid fire manageable and consistent. Field stripping is easy, and aftermarket support is growing steadily, making it a sleeper hit for customization.

Quick Specs:

• Caliber: 9mm

• Capacity: 13+1

• Weight: ~24 oz

• Notable: Interchangeable backstraps, budget-friendly

Best For: New gun owners, value-driven carriers, and anyone looking for a quality EDC pistol at an affordable price point.

Don't Let These Pistols Fly Under the Radar

Choosing a carry pistol is more than just picking a name brand. It’s about finding the right combination of fit, function, and reliability. These underrated carry pistols prove that you don’t have to follow the crowd to find top-tier performance. Whether you're seeking comfort, compactness, or cost-effectiveness, one of these lesser-known models might just become your go-to daily carry. Don’t let marketing hype keep you from exploring these well-designed, proven performers.

Quick Comparison Table

Got a Favorite Underrated Pistol?

If you have a favorite underrated carry pistol, let us know in the comments below. Your experience might help someone discover their ideal EDC choice. Whether it's comfort, accuracy, or sheer reliability, these hidden gems are worth considering.